Top Team Tournament – AFC West

The 98′ Broncos are a real contender in our tournament

The Top Team Tournament is a project where I take every franchise’s best team (post-merger) and pit them against each other. This week I am analyzing the AFC West. In each blurb, I break down the team’s stats, successes, and (possible) failures. From now on, I will be including each player’s Approximate Value (AV), Pro Football Reference’s metric for a player’s value in their career. My goal is to give everyone a bit of background for each team while not diving deep into the histories of them. I will also do my best to not linger on possible heartbreak endings to these fantastic seasons. Along with my background, I will give my brief predictions for the teams in this tournament.

’98 Broncos – In such a storied franchise, picking the best was not easy. However, with some of the top offensive players ever in John Elway, Terrell Davis, and Shannon Sharpe this felt like the right choice. During the regular season, they went 14-2 with the 501 points for (2nd in the league) and 309 points against (8th in the league). They also lost QB John Elway to injury weeks 4, 5, 9, and 10. In his place, Buddy Brister took over and went 4-0 with 10 TDs and 3 Ints. In the postseason, they steamrolled the Dolphins 38-3, overcame a 10 point deficit to win 23-10 against the Jets, and tore through the Falcons in the Super Bowl 34-19. This would be John Elway’s final season as a player.

John Elway QB (Injured weeks 4, 5, 9, & 10) 2806 yds, 22 TDs, 10 Ints Pro Bowl ’98, Super Bowl MVP, Hall of Fame, 203 AV
Terrell Davis RB 2008 rush yds, 21 TDs, 217 rec yds, 2 TDs 1st Tm All-Pro, NFL MVP, Hall of Fame, 78 AV
Rod Smith WR 1222 yds, 6 TDs 125 AV
Ed McCaffrey WR 1053 yds, 10 TDs 2nd Tm All-Pro, Pro Bowl ’98, 79 AV
Shannon Sharpe TE 768 yds, 10 TDs 1st Tm All-Pro, Pro Bowl ’98, Hall of Fame,104 AV
Tony Jones T Pro Bowl ’98, 98 AV
Tom Nalen C Pro Bowl ’98, 132 AV
Mark Schlereth G Pro Bowl ’98, 83 AV
Neil Smith DE 1 Int, 4 Sacks, 1 FF, 20 tkls 120 AV
Trevor Pryce DE 1 Int, 8.5 Sacks, 31 tkls 103 AV
Bill Romanowski LB 2 Ints, 2 FF, 7.5 Sacks, 55 tkls Pro Bowl ’98, 121 AV
John Mobley LB 1 Int, 1 Sack, 93 tkls 58 AV
Steve Atwater FS 1 Int, 43 tkls Pro Bowl ’98, 99 AV

The ’98 Broncos were on another level that year and they will look to continue dominance in this tournament. Depending on the simulator, they have a chance to methodically take down opponents just like this amazing season.

’06 Chargers – This team was a powerhouse that ran through opponents during the regular season (14-2), just to fall apart in the first round of the playoffs against the Patriots giving up 10 unanswered points in the fourth quarter. They had the best offense in the league posting 492 points and the 7th best defense with 303 points against. This was the year they put all of their trust in the run game, Lorenzo Neal and Ladainian Tomlinson, the latter of which winning the NFL MVP award.

Philip Rivers QB 3388 yds, 22 TDs, 9 Ints Pro Bowl ’06, 164 AV
LaDainian Tomlinson RB 1815 rush yds, 28 TDs, 508 rec yds, 3 TDs, 2 pass TDs NFL MVP, Pro Bowl ’06, All-Pro ’06, Hall of Fame, 157 AV
Lorenzo Neal FB Pro Bowl ’06, All-Pro ’06, 18 AV
Antonio Gates TE 71 rec, 924 yds, 9 TDs Pro Bowl ’06, All-Pro ’06, 121 AV
Nick Hardwick C Pro Bowl ’06, 83 AV
Marcus McNeill T Pro Bowl ’06, 53 AV
Quentin Jammer CB 4 Ints, 2 FF, 18 PD, 71 tkls 67 AV
Shawne Merriman LB 1 Int, 4 FF, 17 Sacks, 42 tkls Pro Bowl ’06, All-Pro ’06, 42 AV
Jamal Williams DT 2 Sacks, 49 tkls Pro Bowl ’06, All-Pro ’06, 77 AV

Although they did not reach the Super Bowl this year, I believe that Tomlinson and the Chargers can put a good dent in this tournament. They will give opposing defenses a hard time and keep the offenses honest with their above-average defensive game.

’76 Raiders – From Legendary Owner Al Davis and Coach John Madden came the wild ride that was the ’76 season. QB Ken Stabler was able to put together last minute wins time and time again putting up great passing stats along the way. The defense was young and hungry, if still learning, and regularly stifled offenses before holding the Vikings to 14 points in the Super Bowl. The only loss in this season was to the Patriots in week 4 (17-48), a loss that was avenged in the Divisional round (24-28).

Ken Stabler QB 2737 yds, 27 TDs, 17 Ints 2nd Tm All-Pro ’76, Pro Bowl ’76, Hall of Fame, 119 AV
Mark van Eeghen FB 1012 yds, 3 TDs 76 AV
Cliff Branch WR 1111 yds, 12 TDs 1st Tm All-Pro ’76, Pro Bowl ’76, 108 AV
Dave Casper TE 691 yds, 10 TDs 1st Tm All-Pro ’76, Pro Bowl ’76, Hall of Fame, 61 AV
Art Shell T Hall of Fame, 121 AV
Gene Upshaw G 2nd Tm All-Pro ’76, Hall of Fame, 151 AV
Phil Villapiano LB 1 Int Pro Bowl ’76, 80 AV
Ted Hendricks LB 1 Int 2nd Tm All-Pro ’76, Hall of Fame, 147 AV
Willie Brown CB 3 Ints Hall of Fame, 144 AV
Jack Tatum S 2 Ints 77 AV
Ray Guy P 67 punts, 2785 yds 1st Tm All-Pro ’76, Hall of Fame, 44 AV

This team was full of magic and hype in their time, and I feel that they will need that to translate in order to keep up in this tournament. Compared to other teams in the tournament, this defense may be a bit suspect and could cost them their spot in the next round.

’69 Chiefs – Although the offense was incredible (2nd in the league), it was the defense that was truly dominant (177 points against, 1st in the league). After going 11-3 in the regular season, they made the postseason look like a cakewalk. They beat the Jets 13-6 in the Divisional round and then they beat the team that beat them twice during the regular season, the Raiders, 17-7 in the Conference Championship. Finally, they took out the Vikings in fantastic fashion 23-7.

Len Dawson QB 1323 yds, 9 TDs, 13 Ints Pro Bowl ’69, Hall of Fame, Super Bowl MVP, 144 AV
Mike Garrett RB 1164 all-purpose yds, 8 TDs 77 AV
Robert Holmes FB 878 all-purpose yds, 5 TDs Pro Bowl ’69, 31 AV
Otis Taylor WR 696 yds, 7 TDs 95 AV
Ed Budde G Pro Bowl ’69, 1st Tm All-Pro, 98 AV
Jim Tyrer T Pro-Bowl ’69, 1st Tm All-Pro ’69, 126 AV
Buck Buchanan DT Pro Bowl ’69, 1st Tm All-Pro, Hall of Fame, 122 AV
Curley Culp DT Pro Bowl ’69, Hall of Fame, 104 AV
Bobby Bell LB 3 Fum Rec Pro Bowl ’69, 1st Tm All-Pro, Hall of Fame, 133 AV
Willie Lanier LB 4 Ints, 1 Fum Rec Pro Bowl ’69, 1st Tm All-Pro, Hall of Fame, 108 AV
Emmitt Thomas CB 9 Ints, 1 TD, 2 Fum Rec 2nd Tm All-Pro ’69, Hall of Fame, 88 AV
Johnny Robinson S 8 Ints 1st Tm All-Pro ’69, 118 AV

This team feels like the complete opposite of the ’76 Raiders, insanely stacked defense and an alright offense. Even though they are incredible on defense, it is going to be interesting to see how they stack up against the newer, pass-oriented offenses of later seasons. I believe that they can make it past the Raiders, but it will be hard for them to progress further.

This is part of an ongoing project that I have been and will be updating for the coming months. Let me know your predictions and any critiques I should make!

Next week I dive into the AFC North including the ’78 Steelers, ’86 Browns, ’00 Ravens, and ’88 Bengals.

Thank you for stopping by and reading!

Devyn Smith Twitter: @smithdev002

Instagram: devyn5mith

  • TAGS
  • AFC West
  • Top Team Tournament’

Tweets by RealTheUnderdog

   
Sunday Fadeaway:
Episode 10
Subscribe on iTunes
December 12, 2017
BLITZcast #372
Subscribe on iTunes
September 21, 2017